By Dr. Charlotte Klaar | College Admissions Simplified
This year, more than in any previous year of my college counseling career, I have found myself reminding students and their parents of something that should be obvious: colleges are not expecting 17-year-olds to be fully formed human beings.
They are looking at young people who are still growing, learning, questioning, and discovering who they are. They want to develop a cohesive picture of the person they are considering inviting into their campus community. They are not expecting perfection, nor should they be.
Yet somewhere along the way, we seem to have lost sight of that.
I have been working with college-bound students and their families for more than 30 years, and I am increasingly concerned about what we are asking of our teenagers. Or, perhaps more accurately, what we have convinced them they must ask of themselves.
Today’s students are being sold a bill of goods.
They believe they need to have their names on published research papers before they graduate from high school. They think spending hundreds of hours in a laboratory will somehow make them more worthy of admission. They worry that unless they attend expensive summer programs at prestigious universities, they will be at a disadvantage.
And too many have come to believe that every activity, every summer, and every interest must contribute to building an impressive college application.
When did simply being a teenager stop being enough?
Let me be clear. I am not suggesting that students shouldn’t pursue research, challenge themselves academically, or explore opportunities beyond their high schools. Those experiences can be wonderful. I have worked with students whose genuine curiosity led them to remarkable accomplishments.
But there is an enormous difference between pursuing an interest because it excites you and pursuing it because you believe it will impress an admissions officer.
One leads to discovery. The other too often leads to another line on a résumé.
I wonder how many students have had the opportunity to sit quietly and think about what truly interests them. How many have explored a subject simply because they wanted to know more, without worrying about whether the experience could be documented on an application?
How many have been encouraged to change their minds?
We seem to be pushing young people toward increasingly narrow paths at precisely the age when they should be discovering how broad the world really is.
And I don’t think the problem is confined to college admissions.
Our educational culture has become increasingly focused on measurable outcomes. We reward the right answer, often delivered quickly, rather than the thoughtful consideration that produces a meaningful question. We structure students’ time, direct their activities, and tell them what they need to accomplish next.
Then we wonder why so many struggle to think independently.
Real intellectual development requires time. It requires reading something that challenges what you believe. It requires listening to people whose experiences differ from your own. It requires the freedom to make mistakes, reconsider an opinion, or follow an idea that doesn’t lead to an obvious reward.
These are not wasted experiences. They are essential parts of growing up.
I worry that, in our determination to give our children every possible advantage, we may be depriving them of something much more important: the opportunity to develop their own perspectives on the world.
Parents are understandably anxious. College admissions can be confusing, and the publicity surrounding highly selective institutions only increases that anxiety. Families see stories about teenagers who have published scientific research, founded nonprofit organizations, or developed businesses, and they begin to wonder whether their own children are doing enough.
But those extraordinary stories are not the standard against which every college applicant is measured.
Most colleges are looking for students who have challenged themselves appropriately, demonstrated genuine interests, contributed to their communities, and shown that they are ready to continue learning.
They are not expecting every applicant to have changed the world before turning 18.
And even the most selective colleges are admitting students because of what they may become, not simply because of what they have already accomplished.
I wish more families understood that distinction.
Perhaps we also need to reconsider how we define success. Is it admission to a prestigious university? Is it collecting accomplishments that impress other people? Or is it developing the curiosity, judgment, compassion, and independence necessary to lead a meaningful life?
I know which definition matters most to me.
After three decades of counseling young people, I remain convinced that the purpose of education is not simply to prepare students for their next academic institution. It is to help them become thoughtful adults who can make decisions, challenge ideas, understand the world around them, and contribute something worthwhile to it.
I fear we are losing sight of that larger purpose.
The consequences will extend well beyond the college admissions process. A society needs more than people who know how to follow instructions, meet expectations, and accumulate credentials. It needs people who can think deeply, question assumptions, consider different perspectives, and exercise independent judgment.
Those abilities don’t suddenly appear when a student arrives on a college campus. They need to be nurtured throughout childhood and adolescence.
So perhaps we should stop asking teenagers quite so often what they are doing to get into college.
Instead, we might ask what they are curious about, what they believe, what they have changed their minds about, and what they would like to understand better.
And then we need to give them the time and freedom to find their own answers.
Because the goal should never have been to produce the perfect college applicant. It should have been to help a young person become a thoughtful human being.




